Muawiayah cursing Ali

Al-Nawawi may Allah have mercy on him in his Sharh of this hadith says that the statement of Mu’awiya is not a command for Sa’ad to insult him (i.e Ali) however he was asking him why he refrained from doing such https://sunnah.com/muslim:2404d Spongebob Al-Qurtubi also said that whatever has been narrated about this (Mu’awiya cursing Ali) are lies and not true Spongebob in the part of the narration where it says أمر معاوية بن أبي سفيان سعدًا Its an addition by Hatim b. Ismael Spongebob He is Saduq but has illusions as mentioned by Ibn Hajar Spongebob Spongebob Here is a different chain of this hadith in Sunan Al-Kubra hadith number 8385 without Hatim B. Ismael in the chain and it does not mention that part where Muawiya commanded him to curse. Which clearly shows that its an addition by Hatim B. Ismail Spongebob Spongebob https://sunnah.com/ibnmajah:121 Spongebob In this narration Sunan Ibn Majah 121 ‘Abd Al-Rahman B. Sabit narrates from the noble companion Sa’ad B. Abi Waqqas رضي الله عنه Spongebob Spongebob Here in Al-Isaba Volume 5 and page 175 by Ibn Hajar, on the biography of ‘Abd Al-Rahman B. Sabit, Ibn Ma’en was asked if ‘Abd Al-Rahman B. Sabit ever heard from Sa’ad B. Abi Waqqas, he replied no. which makes this report (Sunan Ibn majah 121) disconnected mursal weakkk Spongebob Spongebob Spongebob Musanaff Ibn Abi Shaybah, volume 18, pages 58 & 59, tahqeeq by Shaykh Sa’ad Bin Nasir Al-Shatri حفظه الله he says in the footnotes that the narration (Sunan Ibn majah 121) is munqati’ and Ibn Sabit didnt hear from saa’ad Bin abi Waqqas رضي الله عنه Spongebob